Developing Distaste for a Script
While in my teacher preparation program, I was told that scripted lessons were beneath me. My coursework focused more on writing and revising lessons than on delivering them. So from the start of my career, I conflated teaching with curriculum development.
I was taught to take the standards for my grade level, adjust my expectations based on my students’ skills, and use my own creativity to write bespoke lessons. If I needed to, I could thumb through the program the district provided, but my job was to make the lessons my own. Scripted programs, I was told, were written by people who wanted to deprofessionalize teaching.
Lost in Lesson Planning
At first, lesson planning felt burdensome. The rest of my job—classroom management, teaching, grading, meetings, communicating with families—was exhausting. But I stayed late and worked weekends to plan. Sometimes my lessons went well. Other times I realized I’d failed to envision how things would go. I’d left out prerequisite steps or neglected to anticipate students’ misconceptions. When that happened, I’d scramble to reteach and make notes I hoped would improve my teaching for the following year. Teaching tested my stamina for trial and error.
Eventually, I got good at designing lessons that were engaging for students and fun to teach. Despite frequent grade-level meetings, what happened in my classroom was different from what happened in the other classrooms. What I taught and how I taught it was unique to me, and that became a point of pride. I felt like I was fulfilling the mission of my teacher preparation program.
Writing Published Curriculum
After years of teaching fourth grade, I took a sabbatical to develop curriculum for a nonprofit. My first surprise was that several people on the team had no teaching experience. My second was that teaching experience didn’t guarantee good lesson writing. Writing clearly and concisely and sequencing lesson steps didn’t require time in a classroom; curriculum development was its own skill.
A point of contention was (and still is) how much to script things out for the teacher. The program I worked on was “softly scripted”—teachers were given suggested language but were expected to riff on it. My favorite part of the job was piloting the materials in classrooms. When teachers chose to use the sentences I’d drafted, I took pride in having written a lesson that “worked.” Studying whether or not students learned was not a requirement of curriculum development. My goal was to create lessons teachers would want to teach.
Observing how teachers interpreted the lessons and hearing students’ responses led to revisions and, ultimately, clearer lesson plans. But the timeline was tight, so only a small portion of the curriculum was field-tested before being packaged and sold. After contributing to a published program, I became even more skeptical of curriculum for sale.
A Bad Script
I first used a hard-scripted program as a reading interventionist. My new district had purchased a curriculum they called “Reading Recovery in a box.” Real Reading Recovery requires extensive training and coaching that my district couldn’t afford, so the box was the cheaper option. We were told that if we taught the program as written, we would take first graders from not reading to reading at grade level.
It didn’t work. I immediately saw the telltale signs of materials that hadn’t been field-tested. Lessons ran short or long of the 30 minutes that we were told to expect. Transitions between steps were clunky, with too many materials to pull out and put away. Over time, I saw that students weren’t making progress. And eventually I learned why. The curriculum was built on three-cueing, a flawed idea of how reading works.
Finding a Better Script
I knew I needed to try something different. Luckily, my school had purchased a different curriculum with grant funds years earlier. After an initial training, the teachers had decided it was too complicated to teach, so the boxes sat unused in a supply room. I opened one, pulled out an enormous binder, and flipped through pages and pages of lesson scripts. The lessons were so dry!
It took weeks to psych myself up to try the new program. I talked with other teachers who assured me, “The learning curve is steep, but once you know it, it’ll become the easiest part of your teaching day.” I went to an all-day training session on a Saturday. I watched videos of the lessons. But when my principal asked if I’d started using the materials, I confessed, “I’m scared to. It seems like the kinda thing that I could really mess up.”
A Script Comes with Expectations
In every other part of my career, I’d read through lesson plans expecting to change them. Teaching is acting, and I’d spent years improvising. The binder was intimidating. I couldn’t memorize it, so I’d have to read from it in front of children, something I’d never done. I was sure my delivery would be stilted. I’d had boring teachers myself, and I dreaded becoming one. I worried my students would think I was a fraud or would hate the lessons.
The program also came with expectations I’d never faced. I had to say and do everything in the script. Each lesson had to fit in the prescribed number of minutes. I had to teach one lesson a day, every day. And I’d know I was doing it right if my students passed a short assessment every five to ten lessons. I had never before been so accountable in my teaching.
Adding to my accountability, my principal paid for a coach to visit periodically and watch me teach. She would have the lesson plan in front of her and a clear idea of how it should be delivered, and she would tell me whether or not I was doing a good job. I was terrified. My whole life, I’d been striving to be a good teacher, but now the criteria had changed, and I didn’t know if I could meet them.
Becoming a Better Teacher
I needed accountability, to my coach and my students’ data, to get started and keep going. But as I continued, my students made faster progress than I’d ever seen. Because every step of every lesson was scripted, we wasted no time. Because the language was so clear and concise, students understood exactly what to do. And because I didn’t have to spend time dreaming up my own lesson plans, I had more time to analyze my students’ data and talk with my coach.
My learning curve was steep, but soon I could deliver the lessons without thinking about what to say or do next. My attention shifted from myself and my own teaching to watching and listening to my students. My coach helped me fine-tune my teaching and she taught me why and how the program works. My first time teaching through the curriculum, I learned more about the science of reading and child development than I had in all my education classes.
Teaching is a Big Enough Job
My coach took me to meet the author of the program, Dr. John Shefelbine. We had lunch and he said things that have been replaying in my mind as I listen to this season of Sold a Story. About lesson planning, I remember Dr. Shefelbine saying:
“Asking a teacher to write her own lesson plans is like telling a surgeon, after a long day at the hospital, to go home and pull out a welding torch to make scalpels for the next day’s surgeries. It’s inhumane and it’s not going to lead to good results. Teaching is a big enough job without adding curriculum development to it.”
I agreed wholeheartedly and I told him every teacher deserved to be given the curriculum he’d written. He corrected me, saying something like:
“There’s a lot of programs out there, some of them are better than others. A knowledgeable teacher who is well-supported could use any of the decent ones to teach kids to read. Curriculum isn’t the solution. A scalpel doesn’t make a great surgeon. It’s the training and knowledge that makes the difference.”
Where Do We Go Now?
Now that teacher knowledge, training, and scripted programs are being discussed broadly, I wish that I could ask Dr. Shefelbine, “Where do we go now?” He died years before this national discussion began, so I have to answer the question myself, based on my own experience.
What can we do to ensure teachers are well-trained, well-supported and have good tools to use?
Here’s what I would want.
For teacher candidates to:
- Learn about cognitive science and how reading skill develops
- Be given high-quality programs and taught how to use them
- Learn how to tell whether a program is likely to be effective
For new teachers to:
- Work in a school that has effective programs in place
- Receive in-classroom coaching
- Learn to use class time efficiently, deliver the provided lessons, and analyze student data
For teachers a few years in to:
- Be coached on how to adapt the program to individual student needs
- Have opportunities to collaborate with colleagues to enhance their teaching and improve student learning
For experienced teachers to:
- Be able to take on leadership roles without having to leave the classroom
- Have opportunities to mentor other teachers
- Weigh in on program revisions in light of new evidence and their experience
Shedding the expectation that we design our own lessons would allow us to focus on implementing them well. We would be freed up to focus on our students’ learning the actual teaching part of being a teacher. Everyone would remember that we became teachers to teach.

